Gretchen Lopez, a Tucson mother-of-three, says she’s in that awkward middle income situation. She and her husband make too much money to qualify for childcare assistance, but not enough to keep their daughters in preschool.
“We’re still living paycheck to paycheck,” she says.
About 7,600 families are on the waiting list for childcare assistance from the Department of Economic Security — a total of about 12,800 children. That’s nearly 600 more children than there were on the waitlist one month ago according to DES data.
The government assistance program requires applicants to be at or below 165% of the federal poverty line for their household size.
Lopez says she had to pull her 6-year-old daughter Luna out of preschool halfway through the 2024 school year because the monthly payments were almost as much as the cost of rent. Now that her 4-year-old is of preschool age, Lopez says she hasn’t even bothered to apply for DES assistance, even though she once relied on that program as a single parent in the early 2000s.
“It’s just insane to me, like how is this 20 years later and we are still here and in some ways even in a more dire situation?” she says.
Michelle Saint Hilarie directs the Arizona Childcare Resource and Referral, a statewide program funded by DES and headquartered in Tucson. She says a lack of access to childcare is making the waitlist one of the department’s greatest challenges.
“It’s a private marketplace commodity. It’s essentially becoming a luxury,” Saint Hilarie says.
She adds that the high cost of liability insurance that daycares and preschools have to pay are hiking up the cost for parents.
“They’ve priced themselves out of the market. Providers cannot, at the most basic level, get liability insurance,” Saint Hilarie says.
The average yearly cost for preschool in Arizona was more than $11,800 in 2024, according to a New York Times report. For infant care, it was close to $16,000 — 16.6% of the median state family income. The rate at which the cost of childcare has increased is outpacing the rate of inflation.
Lopez says she’s met parents in rural Arizona who are taking great risks in a sparse childcare landscape. Some have been leaving their children in hotel rooms while they go to work. Others have resorted to reporting themselves to the Department of Child Safety. Once DCS opens a case, families are able to bypass the waiting list.
“Now that family has that record and it will affect job opportunities for those parents but they’re seeing that as their only option to be able to get safe childcare so they can work,” she says.
Several nonprofits like the Children’s Action Alliance called on Arizonans this week to send letters to the governor and legislature demanding more funding for the assistance program in next year’s budget.
Gov. Katie Hobbs’ executive budget proposal allocates an almost $45 million boost to the Child Care Assistance Program, but the nonprofits say $160 million are needed to eliminate the waitlist.
Michelle Crow is the Southern Arizona director of the Children’s Action Alliance who is championing the $160 million funding increase. She says the state is facing a crisis with access to affordable childcare and that the economics of the field are changing rapidly.
“The stories that we’re hearing is true frustration from parents and childcare providers,” she says.
During the pandemic, the federal government helped fund the state’s childcare industry, which Crow says allowed educators to stay in the classroom and allowed “parents a safe quality place to drop their kids off while they went to work.” But now, she says, those pandemic relief dollars have run out, as have other scholarships that helped families fund their childcare.
“We sort of dug ourselves into the Grand Canyon of not funding childcare and we really do have to work our way back out,” Crow says.
She hopes the letters will send the message that childcare assistance should be considered a priority in ongoing budget negotiations. State officials will release the final state budget by June 30 before the next fiscal year.
Government investment in childcare aims to expand affordability
The Community Investment Corporation is a Tucson-based nonprofit that provides loans and financial coaching for small businesses. Earlier this year, it was one of several local organizations awarded $700,000 to support small childcare businesses that are less likely to get loans from banks.
The award is part of a greater $3 million effort from the state to expand affordable childcare access.
“One way to do that is to work with some of the mom and pop childcare providers to see what they might need to expand who they can serve, increase the quality of their spaces that they have to serve children and hopefully to become a brick and mortar,” says Danny Knee, CIC’s executive director.
Knee says the grant will help keep the childcare workforce running locally.
“It’s really important to have these public funds available to help with what we consider also a public good,” he says. “[It’s] something that doesn’t just help the individuals who can get childcare, it helps our entire community and our economy.”
As Lopez struggles to come up with a plan for her 4-year-old daughter, she’s also looking through a wider lens like Knee. She worries what the long term effects of having less children go through daycare and preschool may be for Arizona’s future.
“If kids aren’t getting the foundation that they need then they’re struggling in school. If they don’t get the support they need they’re just going to tune out and go down different paths that may not be the best for them,” she says.
Whether it’s dipping back into her savings to fund preschool or keeping her toddler at home with her sister, Lopez is scrambling to find the right solution for her family. The mom of three says she’s depending on policy makers to remedy the greater childcare landscape.