The Department of Homeland Security published a draft environmental assessment last week on a planned ICE detention facility in the City of Surprise, and members of the public have until Dec. 9 to weigh in.
The 81-page assessment says the facility would not significantly impact the area’s water resources, air quality, transportation or a number of other elements considered under the National Environmental Policy Act.
“Only limited construction and renovation of the existing facility is proposed and, therefore, no significant adverse direct or indirect impacts to the human or natural environment would occur from the Proposed Action,” the draft assessment reads.
The document describes a 24-hour detention and processing facility that would operate “in support of continuing immigration enforcement activities” within Arizona. The detention center would incarcerate up to 1,500 people at a time and employ 676 staff members.
The planned detention center would operate in an existing warehouse, which was purchased by the federal government last year. The prospective facility stands within a mile of local businesses, schools and city parks. It’s drawn pushback from local residents, including students who attend school near the warehouse location.
While the report anticipated no “significant environmental effects,” it acknowledged the facility would place stress on the city’s water system, noting that the City of Surprise would need to develop a new well “approximately five years earlier than previously planned.” The federal government would fund such projects, the assessment noted.
With its publication of the draft assessment on Nov. 9, DHS also opened a 30-day comment period. Members of the public can submit comments about the draft assessment by emailing icesustainability@ice.dhs.gov with the subject line “Surprise, AZ Comments.”
ICE is selling some of its warehouses — but not the Surprise facility
ICE purchased 11 warehouses across the country last year, including the Surprise facility, as the Trump administration described a mission to “strategically increase” detention capacity to more than 92,000 people.
In June, however, a New York Times investigation found ICE planned to sell seven of the 11 warehouses, indicating some intent from the agency to abandon its initial plans.
The Surprise facility was not listed for sale, the Times reported.
Once the 30-day public comment period ends in December, ICE will issue a final environmental assessment on the facility.
The possibility of a detention center in Surprise comes as people in detention, as well as immigrant rights advocates and attorneys, continue to report alarming conditions within ICE facilities, ranging from contaminated water in California’s Adelanto Detention Center to insufficient medical care in Arizona’s Eloy and Florence facilities.
Repeatedly, ICE has denied allegations of neglect and abuse. According to the federal agency’s database, however, deaths have risen in ICE facilities under the second Trump administration, with the agency reporting four deaths in October and one death so far in November.
Mayes lawsuit against DHS still active
In April, Attorney General Kris Mayes sued DHS over the Surprise facility, alleging the agency had failed to follow federal environmental regulations in its planning process. In the complaint, Mayes argued the ICE facility would be unsuitable to house people, citing its location near a chemical storage warehouse.
In July, DHS and Mayes reached an agreement: the federal agency would perform an environmental assessment ahead of opening the facility. At the time, Mayes celebrated the agreement as a major win, pointing out that once DHS completes the environment assessment, her office can challenge the adequacy of that report.
Despite Mayes’ complaint in federal court, the DHS draft environment assessment does not explicitly mention the nearby chemical facility, though it describes plans to “inspect hazardous material storage areas regularly for leaks, deterioration, corrosion or damaged containers.”
Reached Monday, Attorney General spokesperson Richie Taylor said the office is still reviewing the draft assessment, and did not have any comment on the document.
Who prepared the draft environmental assessment?
The draft environmental assessment was “prepared and reviewed by a team from DHS and ICE,” according to the document.
Another participant in the draft assessment was the GardaWorld security firm — the same contractor that would operate the facility, should it move forward.
“Consultants under contract to GardaWorld assisted the agency in conducting research, gathering data and preparing the (environmental assessment) and supporting documents,” the environmental draft assessment noted.
In March, ICE awarded a $313.4 million contract to the firm to operate the detention facility. It’s not clear whether GardaWorld was awarded a separate contract to manage the environmental draft assessment, or if the task was included in DHS’s March contract. A spokesperson for ICE did not immediately respond to an inquiry on the matter Monday.
GardaWorld is listed as the assessment’s project manager and technical reviewer. Three additional firms – notated only as Rudiarius, TRC and WSP – provided roles ranging from technical review to agency coordination.