Nearly two-thirds of Arizona’s third graders failed the state reading assessment last year. Experts say the future of the literacy landscape is not as bleak as it looks now.
The Arizona Literacy Plan 2030 has been outlined by Read On, a coalition of state and non-governmental entities that is aiming to boost that passing rate from 36% to 72% in the next four years.
The statewide picture
As the executive director of Literacy Connects in Tucson, Sharon O’Brien is part of that solution, and she sees growth in students who receive one-on-one literacy coaching through her Reading Seed program.
“We are learning that kids who are in Reading Seed are gaining assessed literacy skills at a 36% higher rate than kids who are not in Reading Seed,” she said.
Meanwhile, since 2021, the Arizona legislature has tried to close the reading gaps by enforcing mandatory training and examination for K-5 teachers, which adds a literacy endorsement to their certification.
Despite a completion deadline of August 2028, only about 10% of the 24,000 K-5 teachers have actually earned their endorsement.
The question of oversight for the program is a bit wishy-washy. The state Education Department says it’s the responsibility of the school districts to ensure the endorsement is completed, but school districts are saying it’s really up to the individual teachers. And things like expenses, time and test anxiety often cause them to procrastinate.
Pima County Reads On
At an early morning meeting in midtown Tucson last month, a roomful of educators, librarians and nonprofit workers got together to brainstorm early literacy solutions for kiddos in classrooms across Pima County.
They were led by the co-leads of Read On Pima, the local branch of the state’s early literacy initiative. Amber Schlak — one of the co-leads — is a former teacher and the director of Cradle to Career, a United Way youth empowerment program. She encourages parents and caregivers to start the literacy journey with their little ones in ways that might be easy to overlook.
“Not every child comes with the same backpack filled with that language, literacy-rich environment. It's not that their brain isn't beautiful and smart and making connections and thinking,” Schlak said. “They don't have the words yet because they weren't talked with. That initial learning begins at home. Even when you're cooking or when you're walking outside and you're pointing to things in nature.”
About one in three public school students in Pima County are chronically absent — which means they miss about two days of school each month — and Read On has identified that as one of the major reasons for a decline in reading proficiency.
“Imagine a chronically absent child who's missed 10% of the school year. They have missed a good portion of those foundations and they're always playing catch-up. They're always trying to figure out, ‘Well why am I not getting this?” Schlak said.
But perhaps the most common discussion at Read On Pima’s March meeting centered around family engagement and screen time.
“A lot of them coming in, because they have so much tablet time, it takes away from the family interaction. And then they come in and it's like they're not quite sure what to do because we don't have tablets in the classroom,” said Sherri Settles, the director of preschools at Marana Unified School District.
Cynnamon Woodberry is another Read On Pima co-lead. As the director of program partnership with the nonprofit Make Way for Books, she helps teachers and families with children up to age five implement play-based reading strategies.
“‘Once upon a time, then something happened, the end’ is important and it’s critical. And we’re seeing children now will look at a book in kindergarten and they’ll swipe on it like it’s an iPad,” Woodberry said.
TUSD’s new literacy framework
Mrs. Katie Dunne’s second graders are at a vital step in their literacy journey. In a classroom at Hudlow Elementary, they’re learning phonics of the English language, and stringing words together to read and comprehend.
Instead of learning to read, next year in third grade, they’ll be reading to learn. And if these students aren’t reading proficient by then, many would say it’s already too late to catch them up.
Flori Huitt is an assistant superintendent for the Tucson Unified School District, where five schools — including Hudlow — are piloting a new [literacy framework](
“As we build our teacher capacity in really knowing how to teach reading appropriately, then we can see an improvement of our reading performance,” Huitt said.
For second grade instruction, the literacy framework lays out goals like reading high-frequency words and irregularly spelled words automatically, or producing rhyming words, alliteration and sound patterns. It’s all been a big help in Dunne’s classroom.
And she’s trying to convince this generation of iPad lovers how literacy is also fun.
“I used to have test anxiety when I was younger and I still do,” Dunne said. “And I'm like, I don't want them to feel like, ‘Oh no, it's another test. I'm going to fail.’ It's like, no, we're just going to see where you're at. And they actually respond better doing it this way with my reading challenges, spelling challenges.”
Hudlow principal Eva Almonte says the school is trying to recover from the long term effects of pandemic-era remote learning.
“We are having students in fifth grade who are having trouble identifying blending sounds, like that's what we're battling right now,” Almonte said. “And if we think about it, those fifth graders were those kindergartners that came in when COVID hit. So, we are working almost three times harder and not seeing the results that we used to see five years ago, six years ago.”
Almonte says that alongside the evidence-based solutions, a bit of read-aloud time each day might just do the trick.
“I'm telling the teachers: Any chance you get — you get five minutes — read to the kids. Sit them down, read to the kids. Let them listen to a story. Let them watch you open up a book and read, you know, so that we can continue to encourage and model and they get that love,” she said.
TUSD plans to monitor reading proficiency with assessments three times a year, and will start to assess effectiveness of the literacy framework after at least one more year of implementation.