Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Rep. Alma Hernandez not liable for unpaid campaign finance penalties, defense argues

superior_court_outside_hero
C Greer
Pima County Superior Court
Rep. Alma Hernandez not liable for unpaid campaign finance penalties, defense argues

If campaign finance law isn’t enforced, you’re not liable for breaking it — that’s the argument made by one Arizona state lawmaker facing an effort to remove her from July’s primary election ballot.

A lawsuit claims Rep. Alma Hernandez is ineligible to run for office because she owes $20,355 in unpaid campaign finance fines, well over Arizona’s $1,000 limit for candidates. At a Monday hearing, her defense leaned on a 2018 Arizona Supreme Court ruling that found the law doesn’t always apply.

“There’s no liability, as the statute uses that term, because the enforcement steps were never carried out,” argued Daniel Arellano, Hernandez’s lawyer.

Former Tucson city council member Rocque Perez brought the suit against Hernandez. The duo is facing off in a Democratic state senate primary in the 20th legislative district, which includes downtown Tucson. Hernandez has represented the district in the state house since 2019. Between 2018 and 2023, she filed several campaign finance reports hundreds of days late, racking up hefty fines.

Perez’s lawsuit has been consolidated with a nearly identical one brought by Luz Espinoza Burruel.

“This was a necessary component in ultimately being able to appeal to the Arizona Supreme Court,” Perez said after the hearing.

Under Arizona law, election officers cannot accept candidacies from people who owe over $1,000 in “fines, penalties, late fees or administrative or civil judgments.”

But in a 2018 case, Reyes v. del Palacio, the state supreme court ruled that political candidates could not be disqualified for “penalties” related to late campaign finance reports unless those penalties had been enforced by state agencies.

To make its decision, the court relied on another state law, which describes steps for enforcing penalties for campaign finance violations.

In Hernandez’s case, only the first step of that process — an official notice from the Secretary of State to the Attorney General — took place, according to public records obtained by Perez. According to Arellano, the Attorney General never imposed a penalty against Hernandez’s campaign — the last step of the process.

“What’s before me that’s different, that doesn’t result in the same conclusion that the supreme court rendered in 2018?” Judge Cynthia Kuhn asked Jim Barton, the lawyer for Perez’s co-plaintiff.

Barton argued that the election law barring candidates with over $1,000 in “fines” — not just “penalties” — suggests Hernandez can be disqualified for the fines automatically appearing on a public campaign finance portal whether state officials formally imposed “penalties” or not.

Kuhn took the case under advisement, giving her until Thursday to make a ruling. Barton said he would likely appeal to the Arizona Supreme Court if Kuhn rules against the plaintiffs. He criticized the supreme court’s 2018 decision and said it may contradict state law.

“The challenge itself still raised valid questions about how unpaid campaign finances are treated. At a time when corporations and special interests continue to shape decision-making, the public deserves to know who’s beholden to them,” Perez wrote in a statement after the hearing.

Hernandez declined to comment after the hearing. Her lawyer did not immediately respond to a request for comment.