Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Tucson-area Democratic Party chapter considers censure of Rep. Alma Hernandez

alma-hernandez-no-prop-414
Hannah Cree
Alma Hernandez (D-Tucson) is one of several state lawmakers and business leaders in opposition of Prop 414.
Tucson-area Democratic Party chapter considers censure of Rep. Alma Hernandez

A state legislator from Tucson is facing a potential rebuke from her own local party organization.

At a regular meeting on Monday, members of the 20th state legislative district’s Democratic Party committee discussed a possible censure of Rep. Hernandez for her aisle-crossing votes with Republican legislators.

The committee has not yet voted on the censure. Censures are sometimes used by elected bodies to officially express disagreement with somebody’s actions.

Matthew Capalby, the committee member who proposed the censure, said Hernandez has a pattern of voting with Republicans on legislation in the state house.

“That’s not being a maverick. That’s not being John McCain. And that would even make Kyrsten Sinema blush, in my opinion,” Capalby said, referencing past Arizona lawmakers known for crossing the aisle.

Capalby said Hernandez has broken with most Democrats to vote with Republicans dozens of times in each recent legislative session.

He particularly criticized her support of House Concurrent Resolution 2043, which calls on Congress to convene a constitutional convention to impose term limits on representatives. Hernandez was one of six Democratic state representatives to support the bill.

Capalby argued the convention would be dangerous because Republicans would attempt to make authoritarian changes to the Constitution.

His measure sparked sharp disagreements among the Democrats attending the virtual meeting. Several attendees called it an attempt to influence Hernandez’s state senate primary race against Rocque Perez, a progressive former Tucson city councilman.

“There isn’t anything in the bylaws that says anything about censure. It does say, just like in the county party as well as the state party, that we are not to endorse or take a position on a candidate in a primary. Unfortunately, I think this is a precedent-setting thing where, if we do this, it looks that way,” said Paul Eckerstrom, the Arizona Democratic Party’s first vice chair.

When Capalby retorted that the censure wasn’t about the primary race, Eckerstrom argued that it was.

Hernandez planned to be at the committee’s virtual meeting but canceled earlier that day, according to committee chair Rosemary Bolza.

She did not immediately respond to a request for comment Monday night.

“I have always maintained an open door for constituents and welcome good-faith debate and disagreement. That is a core part of public service. However, what is being proposed here is not a debate. It is a process that risks turning a serious matter into a circus that does not serve the voters or the integrity of this body,” she wrote in a letter to committee members obtained by AZPM.

Perez told AZPM he played no role in the committee’s decision to discuss a possible censure.

Hernandez has represented much of inner-city Tucson in the Arizona House of Representatives since 2019. She has drawn the ire of some local Democrats with her pro-Israel and pro-business positions.

Earlier this month, she prevailed in a lawsuit brought by Perez over $20,355 in unpaid financial reporting penalties from past campaigns. Plaintiffs in the suit have appealed the ruling to the Arizona Supreme Court.

Hernandez has not had a close primary race since 2018, when she edged out Olivia Cajero Bedford to win a state house seat. While she has called Perez an “unserious opponent,” the 27-year-old raised almost $10,000 in the first three months of 2026, including from several local elected officials, according to his most recent campaign finance report. Hernandez raised over $36,000 during that period.