Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Tucson educators are fighting an ongoing ‘learning recession’

Katie Dunne Class
Noor Haghighi, AZPM News
Katie Dunne leads a reading practice with some of her second grade class at Hudlow Elementary School on March 26, 2026.
Tucson educators are fighting an ongoing ‘learning recession’

A new report ranks Arizona toward the bottom of the pack in elementary test score improvements.

Arizona students are performing more than a half-grade below their 2019 reading levels, making it the 34th out of 35 states assessed for growth in reading test scores. The report, called the Education Scorecard, says Sunnyside and Tucson unified school districts continue to lag. The report was authored by researchers at Harvard University, Stanford University and Dartmouth University.

Schools across the country have seen a steady decline in reading and math scores since 2013, and not just since the pandemic.

It’s what the scorecard calls a “learning recession,” which started around the same time that children's use of social media took off and test-based accountability in schools became less common.

Thomas Kane, a Harvard professor on the scorecard project, said “the pandemic was the mudslide that followed seven years of erosion in student achievement.”

In Pima County, only one in three third graders scored proficiently on state reading exams in 2025. Ten years prior, the proficiency was seven percentage points higher. Many Tucson educators agree the heightened use of screens among younger students has had an impact.

Tucson educators are fighting an ongoing ‘learning recession’

The trouble with screen time

Cynnamon Woodberry is the associate director of stewardship with the Tucson nonprofit Make Way for Books. She helps teachers and families with children up to age five implement play-based reading strategies.

But she said that can sometimes be a challenge.

“We’re seeing children now that they’ll look at a book in kindergarten and they’ll swipe on it like it’s an iPad,” Woodberry said.

The scorecard suggests that if cell phone bans prove to be effective in the coming years, “we should be evaluating new approaches to reducing cell phone use in school and social media use outside of school.”

Hudlow Elementary School Principal Eva Almonte told AZPM that children’s rampant use of technology, in addition to pandemic-era remote learning, has pushed score progress back at least five or six years.

“Unfortunately because of technology right now, parents just throw the iPad in front of the child, just throw the phone in front of the child. And literacy-wise, it is really affecting us,” she said. “We are having students in fifth grade who are having trouble identifying blending sounds, like, that’s what we’re battling right now!”

Solutions on the horizon

Second grade teacher Katie Dunne is using TUSD’s new literacy framework in her classroom at Hudlow. The framework underscores the importance of phonics and the science of reading, a collection of research that asserts how the human brain effectively learns how to read.

“Far-th-e-sss-t. Farthest,” Dunne said, slowly demonstrating the oral movements of words to her class as they squirmed in their seats.

Both she and her principal, Almonte, said the literacy framework Hudlow is piloting has been a helpful tool for optimizing class materials and time.

Amber Schlack directs Cradle to Career, a youth empowerment program in Tucson. She has a hunch that phonemic awareness was stunted during the pandemic when kids were learning through masks or on video calls, and now teachers are having to make up for lost classroom time.

“Students who need to see the placement of your mouth, your tongue, the way sounds are formed, to be able to clearly hear all that — that was all muted,” Schlack said.

Some of the districts that show promise on the Education Scorecard — like one in Baton Rouge, La. — implemented phonics-based strategies years ago and the same goes for the science of reading. Louisiana is the only state performing at higher reading levels than in 2019.

Arizona also hopped on that train years ago when, in 2021, the legislature enacted a requirement for literacy endorsements on each reading teacher’s certification. The law gives all current K-5 teachers until 2028 to complete 90 hours of reading instruction training and an hours-long exam, though the Education Department says that only about 10% of teachers statewide have earned it with two years left on the clock. Educators that have talked to AZPM have attributed that slow progress to test anxiety, expenses and lack of time, since teachers are expected to complete the endorsement on their own terms.

“They are taking the courses, they're just not finishing and taking the test. So that's where we want to help the field by creating some test prep materials that we can do,” said Linda Burrows, deputy associate superintendent of academic standards at the Arizona Department of Education.

Both Woodberry and Schlack are co-leads of Read On Pima, a local chapter of the state’s initiative aiming to improve the county’s literacy scores. Lately, the literacy endorsement has been a common topic of conversation at the collaborative’s meetings in Tucson.

“They've left it up to the teacher. So, as a district, we're looking for ways to support them. We provide a class. We provide all the information. When anything's free, we’re going to tell them,” said Jill Cordova, the elementary literacy coordinator for the Marana Unified School District.

At a Read On Pima meeting earlier this year, Cordova and her Marana colleagues discussed commitments to improving literacy in the district.

“One of ours is we're going to have almost all, if not all, of our teachers either enrolled or completed the K-5 literacy endorsement, so they have the knowledge that they need,” she said. “And then we were just talking about how that's not the end. After the endorsement, you have to do continued coaching and professional learning for teachers so that their instruction is the best it can be.”

“So much of the information that we’re getting in these courses… were not given to us the first time we went through our teacher prep programs and we need to not only get that information, but continue watching the evolution of the science because it continues changing,” Amy Dewitt, president of The Reading League Arizona, said at an April Read On Pima gathering.

The statewide Read On Arizona coalition was founded in 2013 — the same year the “learning recession” started. Since then, it’s launched several data-based tools, disseminated resource guides and awarded grants in high needs areas. Last year, it launched Literacy Plan 2030, which details a timeline for getting 72% of third graders to score proficiently on state reading exams.

While the questions aren’t all answered yet — like what exactly is causing the learning recession, and why Arizona scores continue to lag — educators in Tucson say that joining efforts and scaling up the evidence-based strategies will help achieve the state’s goals in the next few years.

Tucson educators are fighting an ongoing ‘learning recession’

Noor Haghighi is the K-12 and higher education reporter for the AZPM News team. She also covers economic issues and stories in Sahuarita and Green Valley.