Pima County has adopted two new policies governing future economic development projects in the fallout from the secretive and contentious Project Blue data center.
In July, District 3 Supervisor Jen Allen asked county officials to draft new rules on non-disclosure agreements and environmental impact reports, after she criticized the NDA used by Project Blue stakeholders.
“Depending on the scope of the NDA, they can hinder me as a supervisor from being able to make good decisions that reflect the interests of my constituents who I’m sworn to represent,” Allen said at the July 1 meeting.
The new NDA policy sets higher standards for non-disclosure agreements related to economic development, most notably their duration, scope and who has the authority to sign them.
“The precision of a scalpel, rather than a wrecking ball when it comes to what is covered within non-disclosure agreements,” said Allen.
Under the new policy, the maximum length of an NDA is two years, down from five years. The initial term is six months, and the board is also required to approve the first extension of 185 days, and then again to extend the NDA for one additional year.
Supervisors will also receive a confidential summary of all active NDAs every quarter, after Supervisor Matt Heinz said he was not properly informed he was under such an agreement in the case of Project Blue.
The second policy requires “enhanced due diligence” to measure a proposal’s impacts on air, water, and climate in economic impact reports. One of the biggest criticisms of Project Blue was its potential draw on natural resources, said Allen.
“Missing, as we've continued to hear, was details around water usage, energy uses, scope and scale of initial or full build out and then the potential impacts, what those might mean on air quality, public health and so on,” she said.
The more detailed environmental review is triggered if one of several events occurs, including if the county enters an NDA, or if a developer indicates they are seriously considering Pima County.
According to an Aug. 28 memo, the project details will be collected using a questionnaire, and then distributed to county environmental departments, utility providers, and other local governments.
Supervisor Steve Christy, the only Republican on the board, called the policies a “farce,” and criticized his colleagues for not including more business leaders in the policy discussions.
“It's the private sector that has to deal with it and bring the businesses to our community, and they're not even being consulted on this, and you just heard that from our economic director.”
The policies were developed in two months, and Economic Development Director Heath Vescovi-Chiordi said business leaders were only consulted briefly.
“We did have a brief interaction with the Chamber of Southern Arizona on this as well, but we did not have the time to reach out to the business community at large,” he said.
Christy further accused the policies of discouraging economic growth.
“If we put more hurdles in front of companies that want to look into moving to Pima County, it's just going to make it that much more difficult for us to obtain them,” he said.
Deputy County Administrator Carmine DeBonis, Jr., said the policies will not have a negative impact on economic development, and the policies can be adjusted down the road.
“Though we have fashioned this without fully test driving it, if you will, we're going to learn along the way. And the beauty of it is that we can come back and we can make amendments to it,” he said.
The policies passed 4-1, with Supervisor Christy voting against both.