Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Marana greenlights license for ICE detention center amid questions about abuse allegations

Marana Municipal Complex
Katya Mendoza, AZPM News
The Town of Marana Municipal Complex.

During a Marana Town Council meeting’s call to the public Tuesday, resident Beth Britton walked slowly to the podium and faced the dais.

“I just wanted to share with you how sad I am,” she sighed, “that I live in a community that I love that is incarcerating people. People without due process.”

The following day, the Town of Marana approved a $60 business license for Management & Training Corporation, or MTC – bringing the prison firm one step closer to operating an ICE detention center in town.

It comes after months of pushback against the planned facility, along with an investigation from LOOKOUT News and The Intercept, which reported that when MTC operated a separate prison in Marana several years ago, it failed to properly disclose three sexual abuse allegations against employees during an audit.

But after corresponding with MTC, the Town of Marana found “there were no grounds” to deny the prison firm’s business license, Town Communications Manager Vic Hathaway said in an email Wednesday.

In letters shared with AZPM, MTC defended its track record in reporting sexual abuse allegations, though the firm also admitted it had “mistakenly omitted” one allegation in a Prison Rape Elimination Act Audit.

“While this was an error, there was no intention by MTC to withhold information, mislead the auditor, or undermine the audit process in any way. It was simply an oversight by a new staff member who was assembling the audit documentation,” wrote Mary Calvin, MTC’s senior vice president of finance and CFO.

On Nov. 18, the Town of Marana approved a business license for private prison firm Management & Training Corporation to operate an ICE detention center in town.
On Nov. 18, the Town of Marana approved a business license for private prison firm Management & Training Corporation to operate an ICE detention center in town.

Pima Resists ICE (PRICE), which has worked for more than a year to stop the detention center from opening, lambasted the decision to approve MTC’s business license and called for town leaders to publicly communicate how they would provide oversight of the facility. The group said in a statement it will “continue to oppose the ICE camp,” and was exploring “a number of legal, nonviolent actions to bring further pressure to bear on (MTC).”

Alex Randall, a former MTC employee who first raised the issue of the PREA audit, expressed dissatisfaction with MTC’s explanation of its audit reporting issues.

“I'm disappointed that Marana issued this business license without fully resolving these answers,” he said in a message to AZPM.

In September, when ICE awarded a $335 million contract to MTC for the detention center, MTC said it anticipated opening the detention facility by the end of November.

But as of Thursday, MTC hasn’t set an opening date, according to spokesperson Emily Lawhead. On Wednesday, the day the business license was approved, the firm began listing job openings for the detention center on its website.

“MTC is currently preparing the Marana Detention Facility, hiring staff, and coordinating with the federal government on the timing of receiving individuals into our care,” Lawhead said.

MTC and Marana: The recent timeline

Sept. 29, 2026
An investigation from LOOKOUT/The Intercept reports that prison firm Management & Training Corporation (MTC) failed to properly disclose three sexual abuse allegations during a Prison Rape Elimination Act Audit
Sept. 29, 2026
ICE awards a contract to MTC to operate a detention center in Marana
Oct. 1, 2026
MTC applies for a business license with the Town of Marana.
Oct. 28, 2026
The Town of Marana’s finance director sends MTC an initial inquiry about the 2023 PREA audit, which allegedly omitted three sexual abuse allegations
Oct. 30, 2026
MTC’s Vice President of Finance and CFO provides an explanation regarding one sexual abuse allegation
Nov. 4, 2026
The Town of Marana requests an explanation from MTC regarding the two additional sexual abuse allegations that were reportedly omitted from the PREA report
Nov. 9, 2026
MTC provides further explanation, noting that it “mistakenly omitted” one of the three sexual abuse allegations from the 2023 PREA audit
Nov. 18, 2026
The Town of Marana approves MTC’s business license

MTC’s past: the PREA audit 

Opponents to the Marana detention center have made a slew of arguments against the project — often pointing to rising death rates and documented medical neglect within ICE facilities.

But following a Sept. 29 story from LOOKOUT News and The Intercept, the public’s attention has also shifted to MTC’s past, when it operated a minimum security prison in Marana. (Gov. Katie Hobbs ended a contract and closed the prison in 2022, citing financial reasons and a low population at the facility.)

Under a federal law known as the Prison Rape and Elimination Act (PREA), prisons are subject to an audit at least once every three years. Among other duties, a PREA auditor is tasked with conducting onsite reviews, testing operational systems and interviewing a sampling of prison inmates, staff, contractors and volunteers.

The LOOKOUT/Intercept investigation found that in 2022 and 2023, three allegations of sexual abuse were reported at the Marana prison. And while those allegations were reported to the Arizona Department of Corrections, they never made it into the PREA Audit.

On Sept. 29, ICE awarded a contract to MTC for the new detention facility. Days later, MTC requested a business license from the Town of Marana.

But even the Town of Marana – whose council has declined to pass even a symbolic resolution opposing the detention facility – had questions about the PREA audit.

Marana probes MTC about auditing

In a letter dated Oct. 28, Town of Marana Finance Manager Director Yiannis Kalaitzidis sent a letter to MTC, requesting an explanation about the PREA audit. Two days later, MTC Vice President of Finance and CFO Mary Calvin defended the firm’s reporting processes in a response.

One of the three sexual abuse allegations, Calvin wrote, was reported in April 2022. The investigation was completed the following month. Those dates did not overlap with the PREA audit review period, which spanned from Aug. 1, 2022 to Aug. 1, 2023.

“Because both the allegation and the resulting investigation occurred prior to the audit review period, and consistent with audit reporting requirements, they were not included in the documentation submitted to the auditor as part of the October 2023 PREA audit,” she wrote.

She acknowledged that the 2023 PREA audit referenced a “24-month” reporting period — meaning it would have applied to allegations dating back to Aug. 1, 2021. But Calvin alleged that the PREA auditor had only asked MTC about a 12-month period.

“Warden Jeremy Casey, specifically, does not recall being asked about incidents occurring during the prior 24-month (rather than 12-month) period,” she wrote.

Kalaitzidis, the Town of Marana finance director, received Calvin’s letter. On Nov. 4, he wrote her back, requesting more information.

"Your Oct. 30, 2026 letter and accompanying documentation addresses one of three reports of possible sexual abuse described in the article published in The Intercept,” he wrote to MTC.

There were two more sexual abuse allegations, he added, which had fallen under the 2023 PREA audit review period. So why didn’t MTC report them during the PREA audit process?

marana former prison
Angela Gervasi
MTC, a private firm that runs detention centers in several states, purchased the site of a former state prison in Marana last year.

MTC says it ‘mistakenly omitted’ one abuse allegation from PREA audit 

After receiving Kalaitzidis’ second letter, Calvin acknowledged that her first letter had failed to “adequately address” the two additional sexual abuse allegations, which hadn’t made it into the PREA audit.

Then, she provided further explanation: One allegation had been “mistakenly” omitted from the PREA audit, while the other allegation was “unfounded” and didn’t need to be included in the PREA audit.

On Aug. 5, 2022, Calvin wrote, MTC received a phone call alleging an instance of sexual abuse at the Marana prison. Prison staff reported the allegation to Arizona’s Department of Corrections. The state agency investigated and found the accusation “unsubstantiated due to a lack of evidence,” Calvin wrote.

Nonetheless, Calvin acknowledged, the allegation “should have been included in the PREA audit.” She said MTC “mistakenly omitted” the information after an employee charged with PREA compliance unexpectedly died, leaving a new employee to handle the PREA audit.

The final allegation, she said, had been a sexual harassment claim. The allegation was referred to the Arizona Department of Corrections and categorized as “ unfounded, meaning the investigation found no evidence to support the claim and it was determined the allegation did not meet the standards of a PREA allegation,” Calvin wrote.

“In conclusion, of the three allegations identified in the article, only one was mistakenly omitted from the information provided to the auditor,” she added.

Nine days later, the Town of Marana approved the business license. It remains effective through November 2027.

Randall – the former MTC employee and whistleblower in the LOOKOUT/Intercept story – wasn’t impressed with MTC’s responses to the Town of Marana.

“The audit told the public there were no allegations of sexual abuse or harassment and that the facility met every federal standard. That wasn't true, and facility leadership was aware of these reports before the audit was finalized,” he said.

Angela Gervasi is a journalist and radio producer reporting on immigration and border issues in Southern Arizona.
Related