The concept of the neighborhood public school is fading for parents like Aja Langston and her daughter, Laniyah Gant, whose eastside elementary school might close next year.
Laniyah is a fourth grader and vice president of the student council at Collier Elementary School. During a walk-in protest at the school Tuesday morning, she held up a hand-drawn sign toward Bear Canyon Road that read “Save Collier.” Her friends waved blue and yellow pom-poms in the air as cars drove by honking in support.
Laniyah said her school feels like home.
“I’m gonna have to leave this school and I’m gonna have to pass by it empty and I won’t be able to see half my friends that I’ve been growing [up with],” she said.
Collier is one of five elementary schools and two middle schools Gabriel Trujillo, the superintendent of Tucson Unified School District, is recommending for closure in the next two years. Each of those schools is slated to merge with another school, some as close as a mile away and others as far as 7 miles away.
Cragin, Collier, Steele, Hudlow and Cavett elementary schools are recommended for closure. Trujillo has recommended the closure of Magee and Secrist middle schools.
The district is calling this process “Reimagining our Schools Together.”
But for hundreds of students, family members, staff, neighbors — and even one small business owner with plans to design a “kindness courtyard” at Cragin — who showed up at a public hearing Tuesday night, Trujillo’s argument has not been convincing.
The same goes for board members Sadie Shaw and Jennifer Eckstrom who said, four-and-a-half hours into the hearing, that they would vote against the current closure plan on Dec. 8.
Shaw suggested making other budget cuts before considering school closures.
“If you look around this room, we are pushing around $3 million in administrative spending. We have that transportation audit that said we can potentially save upwards of $7 million,” she said.
Here’s what a few of the speakers said:
“Cragin wasn’t just where I learned to read and write. It was where I learned I mattered and that I was capable.”Isabella Maldonado, Cragin alumna, senior at Catalina High School and volunteer at Cragin Elementary School
“This is part of a concerted effort to destroy public education in this state… They want us to close our schools. And the solution is not to self-destruct.”Finlay Parsons, math teacher at Tucson High School
“We could learn about science, animals, art, music, math, poetry and nature all together. I think being outside is so much fun. It’s an adventure. I want to do these things with my friends and discover even more things we haven’t thought of yet. I really like Collier. I don’t want it to close. Please give us the opportunity to turn Collier into a Sonoran Desert Learning School.”Alden Kiser, second grader at Collier Elementary School
“We were told that, compared side by side, Hudlow is a better school. However, TUSD was approved grant money to redo the roof at Sewell. That tells me that a roof is more important to the superintendent and the district than the teachers, students and community at Hudlow.”Stacey Smith, first grade teacher at Hudlow Elementary School, which is recommended to merge into Sewell Elementary School
“We unite with staff and families who have shared confusion, sadness, frustration related to the mixed messaging from the district: ‘This is financial.’ Another says ‘This is programmatic.’ ‘Your jobs are safe,’ ‘There are staff cuts.’ ‘The team can move,’ ‘It can’t.’ These conflicting messages will only contribute to the distress and distrust at the precise moment you need staff to believe in this plan.”Jim Byrne, president of Tucson Education Association teachers' union
What could happen to the vacant schools if they close?
The district’s current plan with six of the seven proposed schools is to sell the properties starting in the next election cycle, similar to what the Amphitheater district posed to voters with Proposition 426 this month.
TUSD’s plan for Cavett Elementary School is to turn it into a special education campus with the goal of giving students with autism and other disabilities more one-on-one attention. The district said it would be a temporary solution for elementary and middle school students who require behavioral intervention or sensory learning spaces.
But many parents have said they want the district to collaborate with the city or with architects on repurposing the vacant buildings, rather than selling them hastily to developers.
One solution Collier parents have proposed to the district is making it a desert science-focused school. Alden Kiser, a first-grader who addressed the governing board this week, suggested the Collier community could make a lookout over a prickly pear patch, dig rainwater basins, set up wildlife cameras and bake cookies from harvested mesquite pods.
For Lorrie Birch, the mother of another Collier student, the closure process brings up feelings that are all too familiar. Birch and three of her siblings attended TUSD’s Van Horne Elementary School before it shuttered in 2010.
“It sat empty for five years before they tore it down and now it's houses. They're all these cutesy names, like ‘Bookmark Place’ and I'm like — this should be a school, you know?” she said.
Birch said her kindergartener is interested in math and was excited to join the school’s new robotics team. He also loves the music and dance programming at Collier.
“He will learn songs and dances, and he'll come home and do those. It's really helped him come out of his shell,” she said.
Jeff Ladderud lives within walking distance to Hudlow Elementary School, another east side campus slated for closure next year. His daughter is in preschool and Ladderud said he was hoping to send her there for kindergarten.
“For my family, Hudlow is already part of our neighborhood life. My daughter and I enjoy using the school grounds for play, and I value the prospect of her being able to walk or bike to school as she grows older,” he wrote in a letter addressed to Trujillo and the governing board.
He added that he hopes Hudlow’s green spaces will be preserved for community members if the school closes.
“The property’s future is a major concern for me. I would oppose redevelopment into apartments or other high-density housing that is incompatible with the surrounding neighborhood’s scale and street network.”
If a third board member joins Shaw and Eckstrom in voting “no” on Dec. 8, the closure plan will fail.