© 2026
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Millions raised for potential Arizona voucher reforms

Protect Education Act 1
Noor Haghighi, AZPM News
Public school advocates gather in a hall on Tucson Boulevard on March 22, 2026 to kick off the Protect Education campaign.
Millions raised for potential Arizona voucher reforms

The Protect Education campaign has raised $4.6 million so far in an effort to put private school voucher reforms on Arizona ballots this November. About $4.5 million of that has come from the National Education Association, the largest teacher’s union backing the reforms.

Roughly $29,000 has been donated by individual contributors to the campaign from people across Arizona — including in Tucson — and a handful out of state. Jim Byrne with the Tucson Education Association said the local union chapter has collected hundreds of signatures for the campaign and that lots of people are “easily signing.”

“It's a little bit more difficult than, ‘Here's this great candidate and here's why the union supports it,’” Byrne said. “It might take a little bit more of a conversation but for the most part, if you say ‘Hi, I'm a teacher and this bill is to rein in the voucher system,’ most people have at least a foundational basis to be like, ‘Yep, okay, where do I sign?’”

The Protect Education Act seeks to recover millions in unspent voucher funds and would put a $150,000 income cap on voucher eligibility. Currently, more than 100,000 students use Arizona’s Empowerment Scholarship Account (or ESA), and another 1,000 new students are enrolled to use the program next school year. The billion dollars of taxpayer money spent on the program just this year has sucked up around one-eighth of the state’s total budget on K-12 education — public and private.

The reform act also aims to put more guardrails on voucher spending, which has often resulted in fraudulent and unallowable purchases for things like lingerie, televisions and insurance payments.

State Superintendent Tom Horne has continually defended the program’s oversight, telling AZPM in February that he hired an investigator and an auditor to ensure legitimate voucher purchases. Still, reports show millions of misspent voucher dollars have yet to be recovered by the Department of Education.

A competing — almost identical — initiative

The Protect Education campaign has spurred another reform initiative that’s separate, but nearly identical and backed by conservative advocates out of state. The American Federation for Children is funding the campaign, having raised $1.3 million in the last few months.

Protect Education advocates see this as a mock initiative “designed to confuse voters” as petitions circulate through June. While most of the competing campaign proposes similar reforms like restricting allowable voucher expenditures and requiring private schools to administer examinations, it does not propose an income cap like Protect Education does.

Byrne said the Protect Education campaign is doing its best to raise awareness of the counter initiative because if someone accidentally signs it, there’s no backtracking. Public school advocates said the easiest way to spot the “real” petition is with the word “voucher” and the serial number I-09-2026.

During a campaign kick-off in Tucson last month, Raquel Mamani said she’s been advocating for public schools for nearly 15 years and has seen nearly no progress in state funding since. Mamani is a community action team coordinator with Save Our Schools Arizona, a nonpartisan organization that advocates for fully funded public schools. She’s also a middle school reading coach in Phoenix, which she said is a vulnerable role: “a cherry on top sort of job.”

“I spend thousands of dollars every year just for the little extras that our students need. Out of pocket,” she said.

Mamani said her impression of private schools was that they were exclusive, having tried — and failed — to enroll her own children.

“They said, ‘We will happily take your daughter, but your son's just not a good fit.’ And I was like, ‘But I choose you. We have the money to pay, the tuition to pay.’ And they said, ‘Thank you, but no, thank you,’” she said.

William Koehler is a former board member for the Arizona State Schools for the Deaf and Blind. He advocated for Protect Education at its March event, and nodded to the students with disabilities who may have to find alternative schools once ASDB relocates this summer.

“These kids have dreams just like everybody else. Their dreams should not be taken away simply because somebody said ‘We do not have enough money,’” he said, of the students at ASDB and the planned relocation of the Tucson campus to Oro Valley.

Sen. Mark Kelly, a Democrat, recently introduced a bill to repeal school voucher laws written into H.R. 1, or the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. One of those provisions is a tax credit for donations to private-school-funding organizations. In an op-ed to the Arizona Republic, Kelly said the Arizona voucher program “is busting our state budget and threatens to close public schools and make it harder for working class kids to get a good education.”

The Protect Education campaign needs to gather more than 250,000 valid signatures to make it on the November ballot.

Noor Haghighi is the K-12 and higher education reporter for the AZPM News team. She also covers economic issues and stories in Sahuarita and Green Valley.