A judge ruled this month against a controversial agreement between federal immigration authorities and the Pinal County Attorney’s Office.
The agreement — also known as a 287(g) contract — is now inactive, according to a lawyer who addressed the Board of Supervisors at a meeting Wednesday.
“That should be communicated to all ICE officials in the area, so that they're aware of that, if they're not already aware of it,” Snell & Wilmer attorney Joseph Kanefield told the Board.
287(g) contracts facilitate certain channels of collaboration between ICE and local law enforcement agencies. The program has long drawn criticism from civil rights organizations, who argue the enforcement model diminishes community trust in local police and enables racial profiling.
But the PCAO contract had drawn the ire of the Board of Supervisors for a different reason, according to court documents: Pinal County Attorney Brad Miller had signed the contract last August without the Board’s knowledge or approval.
The Board sued Miller in February.
“Although entering into the PCAO Agreement without informing the Board or obtaining its approval may gratify the political ambitions of the County Attorney, doing so does damage to the rule of law and orderly government,” the Board’s complaint stated.
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Michael Gordon presided over the case, ruling in favor of the Board earlier this month. Gordon said Miller lacked the authority to sign an intergovernmental agreement without backing from the supervisors.
“Both a contract that's entered into on behalf of the county and an intergovernmental agreement have to be approved, authorized by the Board of Supervisors. And because this particular agreement was not, it was determined to be void,” Kanefield said.
Kanefield, whose firm represented the Board in civil court proceedings, said Wednesday that Miller has not filed an appeal against Gordon’s ruling.
“So, as of today, the judgment is a final judgment, and it's in full force,” he said.
Pinal County Sheriff: Contract with ICE remains in place##
While the Pinal County Attorney’s Office no longer holds official ties with ICE, another local law enforcement agency works regularly with federal immigration agents.
“My deputies work with and share information with ICE on a daily basis and that will continue,” said Pinal County Sheriff Ross Teeple in a statement following Gordon’s ruling.
The Pinal County Sheriff’s Office has maintained a 287(g) contract with ICE since 2009, according to federal records. The active PCSO contract operates through a “Jail Enforcement Model,” which allows deputies to interrogate people in local jails about their immigration status, potentially transferring them to ICE custody.
Pinal County Sheriff’s Office staff “work very closely with the ICE officials that are present in the county,” Kanefield said Wednesday.
“In fact, they actually share an office in Casa Grande,” he added.
According to federal records, eight local or state law enforcement agencies in Arizona hold active 287(g) agreements with ICE:
- Arizona Department of Corrections
- Cochise County Sheriff’s Office
- La Paz County Sheriff’s Office
- Mesa Police Department
- Navajo County Sheriff’s Office
- Pinal County Sheriff’s Office
- Yavapai County Sheriff’s Office
- Yuma County Sheriff’s Office